Soft Starter: 4 Remarkable Benefits Over DOL Starting

Share:
Motors & Drives
Soft Starter: 4 Remarkable Benefits Over DOL Starting

Thyristors ramp the motor voltage smoothly, cutting inrush current, mechanical shock and pump water hammer.

SCR Voltage Control Current Limit Soft Stop Bypass Contactor

A soft starter reduces the voltage applied to an induction motor during starting, then raises it smoothly to full voltage. This cuts the starting current and torque surge that stress motors, couplings and the supply network.

Hello everyone, today we are going to learn how a soft starter works, why it reduces starting current and torque, and when it is a better choice than DOL, star delta or a VFD.
soft starter

What Is a Soft Starter?

A soft starter is an electronic motor starter that uses pairs of thyristors to control the voltage applied to an AC induction motor during starting and stopping. It sits between the supply and the motor, much like the starters compared in motor starting methods.

A direct on line start draws a large inrush current and gives a sudden torque kick. ABB notes that DOL current is usually 6 to 8 times rated current, and can reach 14 times in some motors.

Industrial soft starter units for three phase induction motor starting
Image credit: Plant Engineering, LS Electric

This type of starter typically limits starting current to about 3 to 5 times rated current. The motor still reaches full speed, just more gently.

Unlike a VFD, it does not change frequency, so it cannot control running speed. It only shapes the start and the stop.

How SCR Voltage Control Works

SupplyThree phase line voltage
Back to Back SCRsOne pair per controlled phase
Firing AngleDelayed firing cuts part of each half cycle
Voltage RampFiring advances until full voltage
Bypass ContactorTakes over once the motor is at speed

Each phase has two SCRs connected in reverse parallel, one for each half cycle. By delaying the firing point, the controller lets through only part of each sine wave, lowering the RMS voltage.

As the start progresses, the firing angle advances and more of each wave passes. At the end of the ramp, the SCRs conduct fully and a bypass contactor usually closes.

The bypass removes SCR losses during running, which reduces heat in the panel. Our guide to thyristors and triacs explains why SCRs drop about one to two volts while conducting.

4 Remarkable Benefits of a Soft Starter

1
Lower Inrush Current
Reduces voltage dips that disturb other loads on the same supply.
2
Gentle Torque
Cuts shock on couplings, gearboxes and belts.
3
Soft Stop for Pumps
Controlled deceleration reduces water hammer and pressure surges.
4
Smaller and Cheaper Than a VFD
Ideal when speed control is not needed.

Benefit 3 is a big reason reduced voltage starters are common on pumping stations. A sudden stop can create pressure waves described by the Joukowsky equation.

Benefit 1 helps plants on weak supplies or diesel generators, where a DOL start would cause lights to flicker and contactors to drop out.

Starting Current and Torque Formula

Start current = DOL current × (V ÷ Vn)
Start torque = DOL torque × (V ÷ Vn)²

Worked example at 50 percent voltage:
DOL current = 6 × FLC
DOL locked rotor torque = 180 percent FLT
Start current = 6 × 0.5 = 3 × FLC
Start torque = 180 × 0.5² = 180 × 0.25
Start torque = 45 percent of full load torque

Torque falls with the square of voltage, while current falls only in proportion. This is the main limit of any reduced voltage starter.

If the load needs more than 45 percent torque to break away, the motor will not accelerate at this voltage. Heavy loads such as crushers need a higher initial voltage or a VFD.

Soft Starter vs DOL vs Star Delta vs VFD

FeatureDOLStar DeltaSoft StarterVFD
Starting current6 to 8 × FLCAbout 2 to 3 × FLCAbout 3 to 5 × FLCAbout 1 to 1.5 × FLC
Starting torqueFullAbout one thirdAdjustable, reducedFull at low speed
Speed controlNoNoNoYes
Soft stopNoNoYesYes
CostLowestLowMediumHighest

Star delta also cuts current, but its sudden changeover creates a second current and torque peak. Our article on DOL vs star delta explains that transition.

The electronic starter gives a smooth, adjustable ramp without that transition. A VFD gives the best start of all but costs more and adds harmonics.

Electronic Starter Control Types

Two Phase Control

SCRs in two phases, the third phase is direct.

Best for: simple pump and fan starts
Economical
Three Phase Control

SCRs in all three phases for balanced current.

Best for: demanding starts
Full Control
Current Limit Mode

Holds current at a set limit during start.

Best for: weak supplies and generators
Current
Torque Control Mode

Controls motor torque for a linear speed rise.

Best for: pumps and conveyors
Smooth

ABB also describes inside delta connection, where the unit carries only about 58 percent of line current. This allows a smaller unit for delta connected motors.

For heavy duty starts such as crushers, mills and long conveyors, ABB advises choosing one size larger. Check the motor full load current before selecting.

Where Reduced Voltage Starters Are Used

Centrifugal Pumps
Soft start and soft stop to prevent water hammer.
Fans and Blowers
Reduced inrush on large inertia fans.
Conveyors
Gentle start protects belts and splices.
Compressors
Lower current on weak supplies.
Crushers and Mills
Heavy starts with upsized units.
Escalators
Smooth start for passenger comfort.

Pumps are the most common case, especially centrifugal pumps with low starting torque. Their load torque rises with speed, which suits reduced voltage starting.

Most units include built in motor protection similar to a thermal overload relay. They also detect phase loss, stall and overtemperature.

Reduced Voltage Start Calculator

Reduced Voltage Start Estimate
Starting values
3.00 × FLC current, 45.0 percent torque

Compare the torque result with the load breakaway torque. If it is lower, raise the initial voltage setting.

Advantages
  • Lower inrush and voltage dips.
  • Smooth mechanical start.
  • Soft stop for pumps.
  • Compact and lower cost than a VFD.
Limitations
  • No speed control while running.
  • Reduced torque during start.
  • SCR heat without a bypass.
  • Some harmonics during ramp.

ABB Softstarter Handbook PDF

PDF
Softstarter Handbook
ABB handbook covering starting methods, torque, inside delta and selection

Reduced Voltage Starting Video

Soft Starter FAQ

What does a soft starter do?
It reduces motor voltage during start and stop to limit current and torque surges.
Can a soft starter control speed?
No, it only controls starting and stopping, not running speed.
Why use a bypass contactor?
It removes SCR losses and heat once the motor is at full speed.
How much current does a soft start draw?
Typically about 3 to 5 times rated current.
Is soft stop useful for fans?
Rarely, it is mainly used for pumps to prevent water hammer.
What is inside delta connection?
The starter sits inside the motor delta and carries about 58 percent of line current.
When is a VFD better?
When speed control or full torque at low speed is required.

Related Articles

External References

What We Learn Today

  • This starter uses SCRs to ramp motor voltage smoothly from a reduced level.
  • Current falls with voltage, but torque falls with the square of voltage.
  • Choose it for pumps, fans and conveyors where speed control is not required.
I hope you like above blog. There is no cost associated in sharing the article in your social media. Thanks for reading!! Happy Learning!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *